Jump to content
British Speedway Forum

Recommended Posts

I'd give it up mate i really would. I keep reading the "everyone i speak to would return if we went Premier league", well most i've spoken to at Foxhall would find something else to do on Thursday nights if the club went Premier League!

 

I would probably still go if we went Prem...the idea of different teams is rather tempting to be honest but it would all depend on how much they were charging for admission. Elite league entrance fees as per this season - I wouldn't go, a price reduction - I probably would.

 

My worry though would be, what if we struggle in the Premier too, especially as other premier teams would have had the jump on us for the decent riders.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To be honest I do think the Louis's should be keeping the fans more updated with the going on's at the moment whatever they may be, at least letting the fans know the options.

 

What I find hard is some of the ipswich fans will stay away if they drop down a league, well all I can say is shame on you as you really can't be true supporters of your club, you are supposed to stick with them through the thick and thin. For example lets take Football your team gets relagated you don't just stop supporting them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't believe there's a single promoter in the EL that thinks that.

 

Promoters want to be successful because it is a sport and you want to win. But they are also business people and want their club to make a profit. Without enough clubs in the league there would be empty racedays and that means no money at all. Promoters want to make a profit first and foremost, and then success on track second.

 

We are lucky at Poole in that we have a very successful club who does make a profit and does win trophies. But without opposition we would have neither.

 

But in any sport there are clubs who win a lot and others that win nothing and just make up the numbers. Take Chelsea and Wigan. Wigan fans know they will NEVER win the Premier league but are happy to be in the top flight. Should Chelsea give Drogba to Wigan to even it up a bit?

 

EL teams all have the benefit of starting equal, due to the points limit.

Really?

 

You use Football as an example, why? This is probably the worst comparison you could draw. Football is everything that Speedway is trying to avoid isn't it?

 

Football has got to the stage where only a small minority of clubs have any chance of winning anything. Football clubs are massively in debt and close to going to the wall.

 

Why not use American football as a comparison. This would be nearer the model that Speedway would like to follow surely in as much as they have a system that is designed to give all teams a chance of winning.

 

In American Football over the last six years they have had six different winners with nine different teams making the Superbowl final.

 

So you see it can be done if the will is there.

 

The difference is their sport is not riddled with self-interest like ours.

Edited by 7oakseagle

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ps what's "Mickthemuppet"s take on this?

 

By the law of averages, the MtM response would be:

 

"What a load of rubbish."

 

:D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
But in any sport there are clubs who win a lot and others that win nothing and just make up the numbers. Take Chelsea and Wigan. Wigan fans know they will NEVER win the Premier league but are happy to be in the top flight. Should Chelsea give Drogba to Wigan to even it up a bit?

 

Unfortunately, you've completely failed to understand that the business in sport is not the same as the business in the real world. Domination is bad for successful teams as well, as eventually their fans ebb away if results are predictable.

 

Yes, some teams are always going to be richer than others, but allowing a complete free-for-all simply generates a spending arms race that eventually puts teams out of business. Virtually no Premier League clubs make money, which is complete contrast to the NFL or MLB.

 

Football only gets away with it because there are so many teams to replace the fallen, and because it has such a profile that there's always some rich mug willing to throw their money away in the name of self-aggrandisation. However, this is simply not a sustainable model for smaller sports, especially speedway.

 

It's ironic that in the most capitalist country in the world, this lesson was learnt early on and mechanisms were put in place to give weaker teams opportunities to strengthen up and help equalise competition. The NFL is the best example of this, and that's why it's so financially successful.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Unfortunately, you've completely failed to understand that the business in sport is not the same as the business in the real world. Domination is bad for successful teams as well, as eventually their fans ebb away if results are predictable.

 

 

 

 

Tell me your joking ? What sporting teams have had fans ebb away on the back of being Successful ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Totally agree, but it seems the only interfering the other teams are doing is trying to sign Nicholls, King etc for their own benefit.

 

If, for example, Coventry were trying to sign Scott then what's the problem? He's their asset. They were forced to buy him so why should he loaned at a cut price or given away free, especially to the club that forced the sale? If they can meet his wage demands and Ips can't then why shouldn't he ride for his parent club? If another club is trying to sign him and can afford to pay Cov's loan demand and Scott's wage demand then why shouldn't both club and rider seek the best deal for their bank balance?

 

All these constant calls to help the weaker/poorer (call them what you will) clubs are missing a bigger issue. By weakening the product you are damaging the business of the stronger/richer clubs and the weaker/poorer clubs are still no better off. It's a sweeping statement but three years ago Ips, Eastie, and BV were struggling and they still are. All that's happened is that the league has been devalued and I can tell you for a fact that attendances have dropped at Wolves and Coventry (because I go to both virtually every week) and I suspect that Swindon and Poole (from some comments I've read) are not in as good a position as was the case three years ago. (not sure how Lakeside and P'brgh are doing?)

 

Either clubs have got to put the cash up front at the start of the season, build a true Elite League and promote/advertise it properly to try to get more people through the gate or everybody admits defeat and ditches the EL in favour of one big league or perhaps the combined clubs of the EL and PL split in to two equal leagues which are both weaker than the current EL and PL respectively.

 

-------------------------

 

With regard to the press release/s - Rather foolish in my opinion. All the speculation will do nobody any favours, a fact seemingly recognised but not reconciled by the second statement issued.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think perhaps someone has realised that the Elite League is only as strong as it's weakest link!

 

If Ipswich leave for some reason or close which Premier League team will be persuaded to take their place ?

 

How would Sky react?

 

Is the Sky deal that there should be no fewer than 9 teams in EL ?

 

I think these questions are more relevant than most of those discussed on this forum.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just got a little bit more information on Linus Sundstrom

 

Linus Sundstrom was not given assurances by the Witches that they would participate in the Elite League and Linus was also not given any sort of assurances that the witches would build a competitive side.

Edited by KingKennethSpeed

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Riders are not so much worried about a competitive team but more of am I going to get paid! Also, Sundstrom as a reseve would probably get loads of extra rides.

 

I mean, Bjerre has just signed for Peerborrough but they are rarely competitive. :D

Edited by Steve Shovlar

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To be honest I do think the Louis's should be keeping the fans more updated with the going on's at the moment whatever they may be, at least letting the fans know the options.

 

 

TBF Prawn, most fans were expecting an announcement after the promoter's piss up in Bournemouth, that is the time line set by Chris Louis, quite unexpectedly we had an announcement saying that 12 o/c on Friday the Club would be announcing their plans.

 

At the last minute that had to be withdrawn, presumably something changed at the last hour/minute which in turn has now set all us Foxhall fans quivering. How what where and whom. :shock:

 

At best we just have to wait and hope that we have a club still in 2011 in whichever league.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just got a little bit more information on Linus Sundstrom

 

Linus Sundstrom was not given assurances by the Witches that they would participate in the Elite League and Linus was also not given any sort of assurances that the witches would build a competitive side.

Lol so does that mean if he signs for Peterboro, it would be his 2nd choice :shock::P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If, for example, Coventry were trying to sign Scott then what's the problem?

 

 

 

Becuase Ipswich, need a number 1, Coventry don't.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Becuase Ipswich, need a number 1, Coventry don't.

Why don't they. Isn't there talk about Harris not staying if Coventry move their race night to Friday because of GP pratice????

 

In which case, Coventry need to keep their options open

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

×

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue. Privacy Policy