Jump to content
British Speedway Forum
Tabashir

Unsatisfactory starts

Recommended Posts

I see your point @OveFundinFan, just think that we've maybe gone too far the other way. Speedway is at it's essence very simple. It can be very exciting but all the rules (and delays) can detract from that. As @DontForgetTheFuelTapsBruv mentions, maybe starting them closer to the tapes so they can't move without touching them is the answer. Or as mentioned in another thread, transponders so that there can be no arguments.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
39 minutes ago, Tabashir said:

I see your point @OveFundinFan, just think that we've maybe gone too far the other way. Speedway is at it's essence very simple. It can be very exciting but all the rules (and delays) can detract from that. As @DontForgetTheFuelTapsBruv mentions, maybe starting them closer to the tapes so they can't move without touching them is the answer. Or as mentioned in another thread, transponders so that there can be no arguments.

 

The rules already require the riders to be lined up 75 mm ( 3inches) from the tapes. You can't realistically get any closer than that without touching them.

Speedway is a sprint and in any sort of sprint people will at times jump the start. Look at any big athletics meeting. The 100 metres final will often have two or three false starts because the athletes are twitchy. Compare that with the 5000 metres where the start is less important and false starts are virtually unheard of.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Speedway is stuck in a rut re starts, referring to the use of tapes. Moto GP and F1 have at least 22 lined up but movement is much less then in speedway. Tapes themselves can flutter due to wind which in itself must “encourage” riders jumping. So transponders need testing, maybe a problem with ruts and shale affecting efficiency so how about a green light start, together with a beam in front and a beam behind to limit movement. But keep them pit gates closed, that in itself would make a big difference.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

MotoGp and F1 also have 50+ laps, so while the start is important it isn't as critical as in speedway.

The tapes themselves aren't really a problem as the riders don't watch the tapes, they watch the mechanism attached to the gate.

Given speedway's spit and sawdust approach I can't see transponders, lasers or any other tech as the solution.

At the end of the day, two false starts in 23 heats seems like a reasonable outcome to me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, E I Addio said:

The rules already require the riders to be lined up 75 mm ( 3inches) from the tapes. You can't realistically get any closer than that without touching them.

Speedway is a sprint and in any sort of sprint people will at times jump the start. Look at any big athletics meeting. The 100 metres final will often have two or three false starts because the athletes are twitchy. Compare that with the 5000 metres where the start is less important and false starts are virtually unheard of.

The 75mm rule needs to be enforced and that would tidy up 90% of the issue

As you say it is almost impossible to move and not hit the tapes from that distance

Invariably though most riders are significantly further back and even when called in by the marshall return to the withdrawn position once he moves attention to the next rider!

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, dontforgetthefueltapsbruv said:

The 75mm rule needs to be enforced and that would tidy up 90% of the issue

As you say it is almost impossible to move and not hit the tapes from that distance

Invariably though most riders are significantly further back and even when called in by the marshall return to the withdrawn position once he moves attention to the next rider!

Of the meetings I see, which admittedly tends to be Lakeside these days the correct procedure is invariably followed. The rules require the start marshal to ensure the riders are correctly positioned be fore he hands over to the referee, who then has to put the green light on as soon as the start Marshall is clear, then release the tapes after a minimum delay of 1.5 seconds to allow riders to get their engines spinning. I practical terms that mean from the time the start Marshall hands over to the referee there is less than two seconds before the green light comes on which is not enough time for riders to start faffy about pulling bikes back and forth before concentrating on the green light.

Because of the nature of the sport and the heightened state of tension the riders are in at the start it is almost inevitable that once or twice a meeting the merest distraction will cause a twitchy clutch finger to move.

But there is another aspect to this that I have only noticed in the last few meetings. Richard Lawson for example is noted as a very good gater but recently I have noticed that he is almost always first up to the tapes allowing himself a full two minutes or more to do his “ gardening, which he is usually quite fussy about, and still allow a bit of time to start getting his head in gear for the race. The result is he more often than not gets either a fist bend lead or positions himself for a second bend cut back. A lot of his points come that way. On the other hand riders that are a bit late to the gate and then start messing around with clutches or goggles or just kicking a bit of dirt around , tend, I think, to be the ones jumping the start. Not always the case, but very often is.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Typical speedway replacing a minor irritation with a rule that is completely irritating. 

If I was a ref I’d release the tapes just as the roller had to stop before hitting the tapes. Also if a rider pulled back as we see some do, I’d get him on the phone after the race and tell him he’s out if he does it again. 

Whilst speedway is essentially a basic sport it shouldn’t be so basic that it can’t adopt technology to help solve this issue. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, ouch said:

 

If I was a ref I’d release the tapes just as the roller had to stop before hitting the tapes. Also if a rider pulled back as we see some do, I’d get him on the phone after the race and tell him he’s out if he does it again. 

That is already the case . If a rider has had one warning to sit still Rule 15.16(b) applies : “ For a second offence by the same rider in the same heat a mandatory disqualification with no replacement permitted” i.e, the rider is out of the race, no replacement no going off 15 metres.

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not sure why, but the forums don't allow me to 'like' posts.

 

10 hours ago, MattK said:

Given speedway's spit and sawdust approach I can't see transponders, lasers or any other tech as the solution.

At the end of the day, two false starts in 23 heats seems like a reasonable outcome to me.

Two false starts and one false positive. Although I mentioned the GP, my main concern was league racing, since that is what really needs to attract (and retain) spectators. Also with the GPs, you tend to be taking in the atmosphere (or watching from the comfort and warmth of your armchair) so it's less of a drag. On a drizzling, cold evening sat waiting for multiple restarts is certainly more of a put-off, especially for newbies or casual supporters.

 

3 hours ago, ouch said:

Typical speedway replacing a minor irritation with a rule that is completely irritating.

Totally agree. Admittedly after many years they've got rid of the 'joker' rule in league now. I know it was called a tactical ride but everyone I explained it to likened it to a joker.

 

3 hours ago, ouch said:

Whilst speedway is essentially a basic sport it shouldn’t be so basic that it can’t adopt technology to help solve this issue. 

Agreed. It may be harder at the lower levels to afford transponders, beams and the like and I have no clue how much it would cost. However, maybe introducing at top level then cascading to  lower leagues if successful could help at least prevent the lower leagues losing money on an experiment.

 

11 hours ago, E I Addio said:

The rules already require the riders to be lined up 75 mm ( 3inches) from the tapes. You can't realistically get any closer than that without touching them.

Hard to tell from a distance, but definitely looks further than that to me. If they were really less than 3" away then it would be impossible to jump without touching the tapes, yet here we are.

 

11 hours ago, OveFundinFan said:

But keep them pit gates closed, that in itself would make a big difference.

Yup, would be far less irritating if they just came back round. No 2 mins for a restart.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
19 hours ago, Tabashir said:

Agreed. It may be harder at the lower levels to afford transponders, beams and the like and I have no clue how much it would cost. However, maybe introducing at top level then cascading to  lower leagues if successful could help at least prevent the lower leagues losing money on an experiment.

Bike transponder are available for under 250 quid I think, and that's a rip off price given they actually cost about 5 quid to make. So probably could be a fair bit cheaper with a bulk deal, although they're increasingly leased nowadays. 

A complete timing system is probably under 10 grand - maybe even 7 grand for a basic system. 

Speedway is years behind even the most grass roots of motor sports. The cost of a timing system is not the issue for the lack of introduction.

Edited by Humphrey Appleby
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Humphrey Appleby said:

Bike transponder are available for under 250 quid I think, and that's a rip off price given they actually cost about 5 quid to make. So probably could be a fair bit cheaper with a bulk deal, although they're increasingly leased nowadays. 

A complete timing system is probably under 10 grand - maybe even 7 grand for a basic system. 

Speedway is years behind even the most grass roots of motor sports. The cost of a timing system is not the issue for the lack of introduction.

Bike transponders were going to be mandatory in about 2002 to allow a real meeting to be transmitted in graphic form to the Fair East to faciliate their lucrative betting industry. That was the only reason why a green helmet cover was brought in to allow punters to bet using their TV remotes. The green cover was to allow the idea to proceed with an expected new input of new big money. When it didn't happen, the green helmet cover was dropped as there was no real purpose for it then, much to the ire and amusement of the usual suspects. Perhaps the reason it was not pursued was the risk of tampering or damage/dislodging of the transponder, resulting in void races which was not acceptable to the broadcaster or betting firms involved. Perhaps the same could be said with such a clinical issue as starting which has to be right every time regardless.      

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As far asI am concerned jump starts are far less frequent than last year.

i think the rules are not tough enough

they should be touch tapes... excluded no replacement

jump start... 15 m

I am sure team managers would then ram it home to not move at the tapes until they go up

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am bemused at times why there is an obsession with equal starts  when there is so much else wrong with the sport , there have always been gaters( Mauger&co) and passers ( Mort&co) some riders just can't gate for toffee.I witnessed Hancock being wrongly penalised on Saturday and he lost at least 2or 3 points, if the tapes are not touched,the rider is within  75 mm  or broken them  let it go .Nine times out of ten times  the best rider will win and these percentages should not be manipulated to give  inferior riders a better chance  .

Cream will always float to the top by trying to  stop this  all  you will get is a ridiculous  amount of restarts !

Edited by FAST GATER
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The entire starting procedure needs to be re-examined and the rules applied rigidly. If the referee stops a race, then the rider who caused him to stop it should be excluded. The rider concerned has either committed a foul or he hasn't - and if he is excluded there should be no reserve replacement or 15 metre handicap. These two alternatives only give an incentive to riders to try it on - and to team managers' to encourage them to try it on!                                                                                                                                                                                                                There is a need too, to quantify exactly what "2 minutes" actually means. This should be two minutes to reach a rest line 2 metres behind the tapes and remaining there until directed by the starting marshal to move up to the start line  (ie no turning round and doing half a lap in the wrong direction.) Riders who mess about spinning their rear wheels or fiddling with their goggles, should be excluded for delaying the start.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Yes, there would be chaos for a couple of weeks but once the message got through, then meetings would run at a much better rate.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 26 July 2018 at 8:55 AM, FAST GATER said:

I am bemused at times why there is an obsession with equal starts  when there is so much else wrong with the sport , there have always been gaters( Mauger&co) and passers ( Mort&co) some riders just can't gate for toffee.I witnessed Hancock being wrongly penalised on Saturday and he lost at least 2or 3 points, if the tapes are not touched,the rider is within  75 mm  or broken them  let it go .Nine times out of ten times  the best rider will win and these percentages should not be manipulated to give  inferior riders a better chance  .

Cream will always float to the top by trying to  stop this  all  you will get is a ridiculous  amount of restarts !

Totally agree.....why does it matter about movement at the start?....why does it matter about getting a flier?.....so long as you don't touch the tapes.  The starts would be less predictable and therefore the racing more exiting. These silly starting rules are destroying good speedway. 

  • Like 3
  • Sad 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now

×

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue. Privacy Policy