-
Posts
24,277 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
29
Everything posted by chunky
-
I definitely think that the circumstances have to be taken into account, and I agree with your views on Pedersen. The problem is that we see so many ridiculous posts on here! Wasn't it only a few weeks ago that people were saying that Pedersen and Hancock should "retire with dignity" (or words to that effect). Are the pair "past their best"? Of course they are. BUT, while they do not perform with the same consistency as they did a few years ago, they have proven that they can still compete at the highest level. As far as the "circumstances" I mentioned above... Let's just say that both Nicki and Greg get injured before the end of the GP season, and both fail to make the Top Eight. While we would never KNOW what MIGHT have happened, it is fair to say that without injury, both would have qualified for next year! Even if they finished outside the Top Ten, I think there would be a strong case for both to receive a Wild Card. Again, this is just to illustrate that the circumstances can make a difference... Thing is, nobody can deny that, even though they are not at their peak, both Pedersen and Hancock add to the SGP. Unfortunately, that cannot always be said about others who have qualified for the series by right, although if they are there on merit, good luck to them! Steve
-
The continuing decline of Speedway
chunky replied to wealdstone's topic in Speedway News and Discussions
I agree, and whatever way you look at it, you are effectively replacing a heat-leader with a junior. Heaven forbid you are two heat-leaders short... Not being negative, but adding to a point I made earlier regarding this situation, here are the likely scenarios: The loss of a star name (or names) can certainly cause spectators to stay away. Replacing a heat leader with a junior drastically weakens a team, so the resulting contest is likely to be "no contest". That can drive away spectators. With an uncompetitive junior (or juniors) on display, the quality of the racing will probably suffer. That can drive away spectators. The key to competitive sport is confidence. Particularly in a sport like speedway, where one is basically competing on a individual basis, throwing kids in at the deep end can destroy their career before it even begins. We have seen that all too often, and certainly back in the 80's when they introduced the compulsory junior in the BL. The vast majority of the kids never did anything in the sport, and it wasn't because they weren't good enough; it was because they had the stuffing knocked out of them, and they lost all confidence. I have seen that happen to many talented youngsters in my own sport of darts too, so I am very familiar with the problems it causes. So, loss of stars, one-sided match with crap racing, and irreparable damage to a youngster's confidence and career... Is that really a solution? Steve -
The continuing decline of Speedway
chunky replied to wealdstone's topic in Speedway News and Discussions
I am totally okay with something like that! I believe that guests are a necessary evil, but that doesn't mean you should be replacing a bunch of lower average riders with guests. For those who continue to compare speedway and football, look at this; when Leicester City won the PL, they relied heavily on Mahrez and Vardy. Not heavily enough though, that should one (or both) be missing from the line-up, they get beaten out of sight. Take a speedway team like Coventry a few years back, who relied heavily on Hancock and Hamill. Take one or both out, and they were screwed. When I said this same thing previously on the BSF, I was told, "That's why teams should have a solid 1-7, with no stars!" Really? Okay, isn't the league watered down enough already? So, just get rid of the crowd-pullers, and worse still, just force them out of the league because they are too good... Steve -
The continuing decline of Speedway
chunky replied to wealdstone's topic in Speedway News and Discussions
The disturbing thing is that while British speedway has been in decline for many years, it was still relatively successful, and largely self-sufficient. Suddenly, everyone is sitting up and realising that we have now reached the point of no return. There is no single reason for the sport's problems, and unfortunately, there is no single - or easy - fix. Of course, the biggest issue is the finances, and as much as I hate to say it, the riders have to shoulder much of the blame. Thing is, the promoters are equally at fault by spending more than they could afford. I accept that these days, everyone thinks they are special, and that they deserve to be treated as such. That applies to all sports, and as someone who has spent a lifetime in professional sport, I do think that many sports have been ruined by money. I don't have a problem with the top names earning more, but I also feel that their demands shouldn't exceed the supply. We all know that hasn't happened in speedway, and I honestly fear it is too late... Steve -
The continuing decline of Speedway
chunky replied to wealdstone's topic in Speedway News and Discussions
Right! We already know that from comments from riders and ex-riders! So, what is the answer? As you say, if we stick with what we have, it will continue in a downward spiral... Looking at comments on here, we accept that there will always be conflicts, and as I said before, everyone is an "expert"! There are two choices, then: 1) Fix the tracks to suit the bikes. 2) Fix the bikes to suit the tracks. That leaves us with these questions: 1) Which will be more practical/viable? 2) Which is more likely to stop the rot? Steve -
The continuing decline of Speedway
chunky replied to wealdstone's topic in Speedway News and Discussions
...and therein lay one of the major issues in British speedway; what the riders want and what the paying customers want are two totally different things! The supporters resent the riders for wanting conditions to suit THEM, when it is the riders who are the ones risking their necks. Of course, the riders then resent the supporters for wanting things that interfere with their jobs! Both opinions are totally justified, but it gets us nowhere. The issue seems to be the modern "all about me" concept, but unfortunately, I don't know what the answer is. Without the riders, there is no speedway. Without the fans, there is no speedway. Looks like we're screwed either way... Steve -
The continuing decline of Speedway
chunky replied to wealdstone's topic in Speedway News and Discussions
That is exactly the way I feel. Speedway evolved from "dirt-track" racing. Watching burly men wrestling bucking broncos through heavy cinders was a spectacle! It wasn't just about passing, or close racing; watching the skill and sheer strength that was needed to keep a bike upright was worth the admission price! Sad thing, it's not just speedway. Now, we have fancy "motocross" on man-made indoor circuits instead of "scrambles" in waist-high mud! We have cool looking indoor trials over man-made obstacles rather than run the risk of getting dirty outdoors. Football went from a man's game to a an over-refined non-contact sport. Hell, look at life in general. We see these Facebook posts about what life was like when we were kids. We went outside, we got dirty, we got wet, we ate dirt, we drank from hosepipes, we played football with metal studs, we fell off slides and roundabouts and landed face first on gravel! "Ooooh no, we can't do that now..." None of that is cool now, and a much duller world it is as a result... Steve -
The continuing decline of Speedway
chunky replied to wealdstone's topic in Speedway News and Discussions
People always mention football, but playoffs do not decide League or Divisional Champions. So, why should speedway? Steve -
Cardiff 2018 21st July
chunky replied to racers and royals's topic in Speedway Grand Prix and Speedway World Cup
You okay, mate? Not like you to hold back!!! Steve -
The continuing decline of Speedway
chunky replied to wealdstone's topic in Speedway News and Discussions
Ah, the days of Mr. Nelson Mills Baldwin OBE... Steve -
The continuing decline of Speedway
chunky replied to wealdstone's topic in Speedway News and Discussions
Come on, ALL of us that have been around for 40+ years are cynical! Thing is, I know that, the older we get, the more cynical we get, but in the case of British speedway, there are very good reasons for our cynicism! Steve -
The continuing decline of Speedway
chunky replied to wealdstone's topic in Speedway News and Discussions
I honestly don't think it SHOULD be a problem for a rider to ride for multiple teams across Europe. The important thing is that, whoever he rides for, he should be there, injuries not withstanding. If there is a clash of fixtures due to a rescheduling, the fixture that was originally scheduled for that date should take priority. Steve -
Swedish GP 2018 Hallstavik
chunky replied to Ghostwalker's topic in Speedway Grand Prix and Speedway World Cup
..and the fact that Hancock is STILL one of the best 8 riders... Steve -
Swedish GP 2018 Hallstavik
chunky replied to Ghostwalker's topic in Speedway Grand Prix and Speedway World Cup
So, even though he is still proving himself to be one of the better riders, you DO want them to pick who you want? Oh well... Steve -
Swedish GP 2018 Hallstavik
chunky replied to Ghostwalker's topic in Speedway Grand Prix and Speedway World Cup
So, do you want them to just choose the riders YOU want? Steve -
Swedish GP 2018 Hallstavik
chunky replied to Ghostwalker's topic in Speedway Grand Prix and Speedway World Cup
Here we go.. Sigh... Steve -
Swedish GP 2018 Hallstavik
chunky replied to Ghostwalker's topic in Speedway Grand Prix and Speedway World Cup
If people are in the series on merit (qualifying by right), nobody should dismiss their efforts. And that also includes Cook. Steve -
Swedish GP 2018 Hallstavik
chunky replied to Ghostwalker's topic in Speedway Grand Prix and Speedway World Cup
Who was that in white, and what did he do with Cook??? Steve -
Swedish GP 2018 Hallstavik
chunky replied to Ghostwalker's topic in Speedway Grand Prix and Speedway World Cup
From the GP website. You have to sign up for an account, but it is free. Steve -
The continuing decline of Speedway
chunky replied to wealdstone's topic in Speedway News and Discussions
Funny, isn't it? The BSF used to be full of people complaining that the lack of great racing is killing the sport, and how much better the racing USED to be. Now, thanks to videos which dispel all those misconceptions, it is amazing to realise the truth, and the racing really WASN'T better back then. Even to watch live streams from thousands of miles away, the lack of atmosphere - and people - is so evident. Being at Wembley on World Final night. or standing on the pit bend at Plough Lane mocking the 'ackney fans, it really is the people who made the difference. Sigh... Steve -
The continuing decline of Speedway
chunky replied to wealdstone's topic in Speedway News and Discussions
How long have I been saying that??? Steve -
The continuing decline of Speedway
chunky replied to wealdstone's topic in Speedway News and Discussions
I know what you are trying to say, but it is "grass-track", not speedway. Even though a fair few riders who do both, they are two different sports, at totally different venues, with totally different fans. On here, you see many complaints that the Speedway Star "includes grass-track". To me, they are close enough to warrant grass-track news in speedway mags, but they are not the same sport. I am also aware that grass-track has taken a nose-dive in the UK too, which actually surprises me. One of the things that fans - including myself - loved about grass-track was the access we had to the riders and their machines. I maintain that one of the best ways to attract new fans to the sport is for them to get close to the machinery and the riders. A few years ago, there was a general motorsports event up in Minnesota, and I went up there with former Workington rider James Mann, who was giving a speedway display with a couple of others. As it was, the meeting was rained off (yeah, 1300 mile round trip for a rain-off...), but in the short time we were there, everybody was so fascinated by the bikes. That's why I love the ideas of riders taking bikes to schools. Yes, I was suggesting that something drastic needs to happen, but you and I both know that we aren't going to find "serious financial backing". That is why we have to cut costs. I just don't know what we can actually get away with. The SGP was innovative thinking, but at that time, the sport as a whole was relatively healthy. We are now talking about something to heal British speedway only, but the fact that British speedway is now on life-support makes it an extremely delicate situation. Just sitting here making suggestions - and waiting for some major sponsor to simply dump a ton of cash into the sport - isn't going to achieve anything. Even if we did find someone with money, five years down the road we will be sitting here replicating these threads, except that the crowds will be down to the 100-150 mark. We NEED to change/update the product, and the way it is displayed. Steve