Aries Posted 40 minutes ago Author Report Share Posted 40 minutes ago (edited) 6 minutes ago, lucifer sam said: I could see the Swedish GP appearance was a wildcard, but the rule says AND, so I think the intention is that you do add them together. He appeared 3 times in the 2024 Grand Prix, so it counts You’re wrong. “Excluding wild card riders, and a reserve rider who has competed in two or less FIM GP rounds” Take the wild card appearance completely out of the equation. He competed in two or less meetings as track reserve. He’s 4.50. Edited 39 minutes ago by Aries Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
lucifer sam Posted 35 minutes ago Report Share Posted 35 minutes ago 2 minutes ago, Aries said: You’re wrong. “Excluding wild card riders, and a reserve rider who has competed in two or less FIM GP rounds” Take the wild card appearance completely out of the equation. He competed in two or less meetings as track reserve. He’s 4.50. Nice try - but you've inserted a comma that doesn't exist in the rulebook 😆 I copied and pasted from the rulebook - I didn't do any editing as you have! He should be 8.00 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Aries Posted 26 minutes ago Author Report Share Posted 26 minutes ago 1 minute ago, lucifer sam said: Nice try - but you've inserted a comma that doesn't exist in the rulebook 😆 I copied and pasted from the rulebook - I didn't do any editing as you have! He should be 8.00 You’re still wrong. What difference does the comma make? the rule is clear and you’re clearly being obtuse. How many meetings, did Nilsson compete as a GP reserve in 2024? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
FishersGate Posted 25 minutes ago Report Share Posted 25 minutes ago 22 minutes ago, Aries said: Not at Ipswich. He wouldn’t fit. Only the current GP “Star” and current Swedish National champion, fits. 😛 Ah didn't tealise Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
lucifer sam Posted 16 minutes ago Report Share Posted 16 minutes ago 4 minutes ago, Aries said: You’re still wrong. What difference does the comma make? the rule is clear and you’re clearly being obtuse. How many meetings, did Nilsson compete as a GP reserve in 2024? It makes all the difference in this case - as I think you know full well. Look, I know you're an Ipswich fan and you will argue all day that Nilsson can come in on a 4.50. And maybe he will. But, according to that wording, he should come in an 8.00 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Aries Posted 14 minutes ago Author Report Share Posted 14 minutes ago 1 minute ago, lucifer sam said: It makes all the difference in this case - as I think you know full well. Look, I know you're an Ipswich fan and you will argue all day that Nilsson can come in on a 4.50. And maybe he will. But, according to that wording, he should come in an 8.00 Answer the bloody question 😂 How many appearances did Kim Nillson make as track reserve in 2024? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Witches1998 Posted 13 minutes ago Report Share Posted 13 minutes ago I read the rule that wild card rides dont count so exclude that round then he only rode 2 as reserve meaning he doesnt meet the 8 rule and is actually the 4.50 he needs to be to fit But im not in the know and just interpreting the rules, any in the knows who had heard nilsson know if hes still happening?! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Aries Posted 5 minutes ago Author Report Share Posted 5 minutes ago 1 minute ago, Witches1998 said: I read the rule that wild card rides dont count so exclude that round then he only rode 2 as reserve meaning he doesnt meet the 8 rule and is actually the 4.50 he needs to be to fit But im not in the know and just interpreting the rules, any in the knows who had heard nilsson know if hes still happening?! Exactly how the rule is written. Wildcard: Exempt. Two or less meetings as Reserve: Exempt. Nilsson rode one wildcard meeting, and two meetings as track reserve. Nobody is trying to twist any rules because “you’re an Ipswich fan” ffs 🤣 They’re the written SCB regulations. As has been said on here and many times now, is that we don’t know as yet if those regulations apply in 2027. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
lucifer sam Posted 5 minutes ago Report Share Posted 5 minutes ago 6 minutes ago, Aries said: Answer the bloody question 😂 How many appearances did Kim Nillson make as track reserve in 2024? Two, plus an appearance as a wildcard. And last time I checked 2+1=3. There's no comma in that entire sentence in the rulebook - so you add all the appearances together. You're reading the AND as an OR for some reason Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
lucifer sam Posted 3 minutes ago Report Share Posted 3 minutes ago Just now, Aries said: Exactly how the rule is written. Wildcard: Exempt. Two or less meetings as Reserve: Exempt. Nilsson rode one wildcard meeting, and two meetings as track reserve. Nobody is trying to twist any rules because “you’re an Ipswich fan” ffs 🤣 They’re the written SCB regulations. As has been said on here and many times now, is that we don’t know as yet if those regulations apply in 2027. The rulebook doesn't say this OR this. It says this AND this. So add it together Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Aries Posted 1 minute ago Author Report Share Posted 1 minute ago 2 minutes ago, lucifer sam said: Two, plus an appearance as a wildcard. And last time I checked 2+1=3. There's no comma in that entire sentence in the rulebook - so you add all the appearances together. You're reading the AND as an OR for some reason You have to exclude wildcard riders and riders riding in two or less meetings as a track reserve. Nilsson meets the exemption criteria. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Aries Posted just now Author Report Share Posted just now I give up. Crack on Sunshine. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.